I honestly don’t remember asking any of my elders what
reservation was. Considering that “arakshan” is in the news eight out of seven
days of the week, I should’ve asked the question anyway at some point of time. But
seems like I’ve heard about it since forever, and maybe that’s why, there was
never a need to ask.
The whole CONCEPT of reservation in India gets me angry. And
so, I might seem biased as you read. I might even be.
Personally, I’ve seen a lot of my cousins fly out to study,
or to work. I always asked why. My cousins’ response? “Well, if I have to get a 107% to get into a
reputed institution, or have to be in the 0.01% general category to get a
government job, I’d rather go to Somalia.” Sure we would laugh about it, but
there was resentment. We all knew it, we all had it. Talk about brain drain.
Reservations were introduced in independent India to battle
the caste system. It was introduced to bridge the gap between the so called
upper castes and the ‘dalits’. But we forget that it was to be abandoned after
a few decades of independence. That would be the government’s job. However,
that would mean a massive loss of votes, because well, vote banks. Today, even
the financially comfortable ‘scheduled castes’ make use of the reserved
facility. They have access to the best facilities, get the best of education,
and yet go for the quota. Who wouldn’t if they had the opportunity? Lower
qualifications, easy seats. I’ve had friends who’ve availed the same. This was
not what the reservations had been introduced for.
Don’t get me wrong here, I’m all for equality and giving
opportunity to the disadvantaged. However, I don’t think giving reservations on
the basis of ancient caste systems. Reservations should be given. But on one’s
economic status, not social.
Reservations were established to do away the differences
between the so called upper and lower castes. However, reservations aren’t
doing it. If anything, the divide is growing, bigger and stronger, with the
resentment that the general caste feels towards them. There’s a need to uplift
the masses, there’s a need for quality and this will come through reservation,
but not based on some ancient caste system, but based on economic status. We
need change. And we need it now.
Ana Saran
20153002
How is this linked to material discussed in class? Are you saying that reservation can be provided but on different criteria? If so, how do we arrive at those in a democratic context?
ReplyDelete